A New York judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by a conservative group against city pension funds for their decision to divest billions of dollars from fossil fuel investments.
New York State Supreme Court Justice Andrea Masley said in an order that the group and three public sector employees lack legal standing to bring the lawsuit.
Additionally, the judge rules that the plaintiffs are members of a defined-benefit pension plan entitled to a fixed payment every month and, therefore, wouldn’t be harmed by the divestment decision in any case.
”Plaintiffs here have not, and will not, suffer any monetary losses based upon defendants’ investment decisions,” the judge ruled in her order.
She found the retired workers’ claims about the plans’ potential inability to fulfil future obligations to be speculative.
Additionally, she pointed out that the workers acknowledged that the city’s taxpayers are ultimately responsible for meeting pension obligations.
New York City Comptroller Brad Lander said in a statement, “This is a big win for common-sense responsible investing, New York City’s municipal workers and retirees, and for the future of the City and the planet.”
Read more: New report reveals surge in climate litigation against polluters
The plaintiffs, including Americans for Fair Treatment, filed a lawsuit against three New York City retirement plans last year over their decision to divest approximately $4 billion from fossil fuel investments, describing it as “a misguided and ineffectual gesture to address climate change.”
Donald Nesbit, Executive Vice President of Local 372 and DC37 VP/ Political Action Chair, added, “Being a trustee is not an easy job, but as fiduciaries, we use prudence and integrity when making the decisions that we make. I am excited to hear that the New York State Supreme Court saw it that way as well.”