ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investing had a tough time in the last three months of 2023. ESG funds in the US lost over $5 billion, and globally, there were overall withdrawals from these funds for the first time ever.
This has sparked a debate about the future of ESG investing. While some think it’s struggling because it has become too political, others who are close to the industry, have a different perspective.
Valentijn van Nieuwenhuijzen, who leads sustainability efforts for public market investments at Goldman Sachs Asset Management, suggests that investors are observing a slow development that will eventually lead to ESG fund movements closely aligning with the overall market.
“As baseline sustainability integration increases, overall fund flows are likely to mirror broader trends in equity and fixed-income markets,” he told Bloomberg.
“Sustainability-focused investors are increasingly looking to products that target differentiated themes within ESG or add balance to broader portfolios,” according to Van Nieuwenhuijzen.
Hannah Lee, JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s head of ESG equity research for the Asia-Pacific region, says “There are still robust pockets of demand for ESG investing.”
“But the recent underperformance of sustainable funds has been a challenge,” Lee said.
In recent times, corporate executives have been discussing ESG much less. The use of this term in earnings calls with analysts and investors during the fourth quarter has dropped to the lowest point since late 2020, as per Bloomberg’s data.