Amidst increasing scrutiny over environmental, social, and governance (ESG) practices, insurers are grappling with concerns surrounding greenwashing, according to a recent survey conducted by Ortec Finance.
The survey, targeting investment management professionals within the life insurance, London markets re/insurers, and investment managers serving the insurance sector, revealed growing apprehensions regarding greenwashing amid tightening ESG criteria.
Almost half (45%) of respondents expressed significant concern about greenwashing in investment practices, with an additional 53% expressing moderate concern. Despite these worries, there is a clear intent among insurers to increase investments in green bonds and specialized climate-focused funds within the next two years.
Specifically, 62% of participants plan to boost their allocations of green bonds, while a significant 75% aim to do so for climate-focused funds.
However, there is an underlying anxiety that the range of investable options for insurers might shrink due to stricter ESG mandates. Approximately 80% of those surveyed expect a reduction in available investment opportunities due to ESG constraints, with 9% foreseeing a considerable contraction.
The study also highlighted the industry’s self-assessment of current ESG strategies and programs. Only 18% of respondents viewed the industry’s ESG initiatives as very good, a figure that marginally increased to 21% when evaluating practices within their own organizations.
Fears over meeting ESG targets are also prevalent in the sector, as revealed by a recent Gallagher study.
Commenting on the survey results, Hamish Bailey, managing director UK and head of insurance & investment at Ortec Finance, emphasized the robust demand among insurers and insurance asset managers for specialist climate-focused funds and green bonds.
“However, this is countered by mounting concerns over greenwashing and the anticipation that investment options will diminish as ESG criteria tighten,” Bailey said. “Insurers are increasingly in need of guidance to identify investments that are both beneficial for their portfolios and compliant with ESG standards, necessitating a more rigorous scrutiny of greenwashing practices.”